Finally managed to catch up with the BSG finale last night (aka the UK transmission). I can certainly see why some people loved it, some people hated it and some people are still confused. As a friend of mine remarked "Once you bring religion in, you lower my sense of belief." He then proceeded to explain that yes, he did know it was a sci-fi show, but I digress.
Overall, for a show that was always more about the characters than the plot, it got the finale it deserved.
Two final notes: what the f--- was all that stuff about a thirteenth cylon named Daniel all about then if it didn't pay off? And let's face it - there really wasn't a plan. Cylon or otherwise.